Recently read

Beyond Heaving Bosoms:  The Smart Bitches’ Guide to Romance Novels.  
Enjoyed the analysis of genre romance, which was critical but not written in academic-ese.  I think this is a valuable resource both for romance readers and for anyone interested in popular culture and/or lit studies.  Content-wise, the contemporary romance got very little attention in comparison to historicals and paranormals, which sort of makes sense given current publishing trends, but makes less so when looking at the broader picture of genre romance.  My biggest quibble:  the selection of The Flame and the Flower in 1972 as predecessor of the modern romance novel ignores the Mills & Boon/Harlequin romances were published decades before, with tropes and formulae that can still be found in modern romance.  Mills&Boon/Hqn got relatively little page space, which was suprising given their influence in the genre, historically speaking. 

On a personal level, I loved the Old/New Skool flowchart and other tables, but occasionally found the formatting (flowing over mulitple pages and non-facing pages) a little distracting.  And the voice/tone that entertains for a blog post grew wearing after 100 pages or so.  Appreciated the Bujold/Miles love when talking about the appeal of paranormal/fantasy romance for cross-over audiences, although I’m not sure that the Vorkosigan series really fits either category.  YMMV, though.  B/B+.

Practice Makes Perfect by Julie James.  

I like James’s voice.  This was a funny, well-paced book.  Wasn’t sure about the heroine at first, but she grew on me; the hero began to — he seemed like an immature jerk for most of the book, edged toward being likeable, then turned into a total asshat.  The Big Gesture at the end?  Too late (for me, obviously not for the heroine or a lot of other readers). 

It was interesting that Payton supposedly could be quite a bitch, at least according to herself and to JD, but she never actually was — maybe she had been in the past, but not so on these pages.  Any bitchery plotted or planned was always forestalled by the needs of a disinterested third party (can’t let an innocent be harmed!) or a lameass apology from JD.  Because romance heroines can’t be bitchy?  They aren’t allowed to intentionally do truly nasty things?  Because heroines aren’t supposed to be anything but nice?  Can’t have her do something mean without provocation and with premeditation, even if it is retaliatory?  Only heroes can? 

Despite the fact that I never warmed to JD, the book was a B until almost the end; the ending gets a solid D, which averages out to a C, I guess. 

Unrelated:  Does someone on Nole’s team think the smurf shoes are flattering?  Blue shoes should be left to Elvis. 

Edited — holy SpellCheck, Batman, what a lot of typos I found!



Filed under Uncategorized

10 responses to “Recently read

  1. I adored Practice Makes Perfect. There was just something about it, the dynamics between JD and Payton that cracked me up.
    The court scene with Payton made me laugh so hard my stomach hurt.
    Have you read Just the Sexiest Man Alive? I think you would enjoy that one better because the heroine is the opposite of Payton.

    • Thanks for the recommendation πŸ™‚ I have read Just the Sexiest Man Alive, and I liked that heroine, too. Again, the hero in that book fell flat for me. So far, I’ve liked James’s voice and the humor in each book, though, so I’ll try whatever she publishes next.

  2. Hmms. There’s so much buzz about it that I am wavering between just buying Practice Makes Perfect or going through an interlibrary loan (from the ONE library on my system that has it). Not like I SHOULD be peering at more books at the rate the TBR is growing… *smacks self*.

    • I’m happy to pass my copy on if you like.

      • I would love that! Want to set up a trade?

      • A trade would be nice, but isn’t necessary — the book isn’t a keeper for me, and will either go to paperbackswap or the library donation pile if left on my shelves πŸ™‚

      • OK I’ll look at my bookshelves at home and give you a list to choose from. UNLESS you want a copy of Clockwork Heart by Dru Pagliassotti, which I just read and I want to make everyone else read and talk about it? It is AWESOME but I did notice at least 3 typos (missing words, words repeated twice, a couple wrong words), and if I noticed you surely will.

      • OK I peered a bit at my bookshelves. Any interest in:
        Nightwalker by Jocelynn Drake (I got this copy used)
        Private Arrangements by Sherry Thomas (read once, nice copy)
        Three nice copies of:
        Red Handed by Gena Showalter (YA)
        Darcy’s Story by Janet Aylmer
        The Hunter’s Moon by O.R.Melling
        Most are close to keepers but not quite or I had extra copies.
        Also I have (unread, new, not sure if I’ll ever get to them so offering):
        Overkill by Linda Castillo
        Scandal’s Daughter by Christine Wells.

      • Actually, I’ll try the Dru Pagliassotti book you mentioned. New to me author.
        If you’ll send a mailing address via LJ or my email (jmcarr2001 at yahoo), I’ll post PMP this weekend.

  3. Anonymous

    that excerpt is pure gold!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s